Oh yes, this is the only other version I've seen besides the movie and it is really lovely! (Same with me, I saw the movie first and it will always be my favorite) I especially loved when all the old Phantoms sang together at the end, it was amazing!

I actually liked this version of Raoul better because he seemed more sensible. And he was really funny in the underground cave scene at the end. I was pretty sure he was going to pop through the rope he was so angry the Phantom was wooing Christine!

One thing that kind of bugged me was most of Sierra Boggess' costumes were cut off below the knee and looked really weird to me. I much perfer Emmy Rossum's gorgeous gowns in the movie!